Sartre gave us the Idea of the One...de Beauvoir uses the example of Sartre's the One, and describes its contrast, as the Others. She points out the fact, the curse if you will, of dialectic thinking, is that to be the One, dialectically those who are not the One, are the Others.
Western rationalists for the main part of their society’s histories have maintained that the dominant male in its society, is the One, and that in contrast, minorities, children and women are the Others. There is an implied bias due to the use of dialectic reasoning. de Beauvoir show us that with this concept of the One, the One being the best that nature can provide, (much like Nietzsche), the Others are cast as being less than the One. That Is, without the One, the Others cannot exist beneficially by themselves. This of course means that the Others should be treated like children are treated by their parents. They need to be ruled, and controlled, because they do not have the cognitive or emotional control and understanding that a parent poses.
The One is what many described as the Master Class. The natural rulers that nature or God has placed as leaders in a society. de Beauvoir show us this is not true in nature, it is only true in our minds. In her work, The Second Sex, she states:
“But there are deep similarities between the situation of Women and that of the Negro. Both are being emancipated today from a like paternalism, and the former master class wishes to “Keep them in their place”-that is, the place chosen for them” (Sterba, p330)
de Beauvoir shows that the dialectic mind of the One, the dominant ruling caste, projects their own need for the Other, onto those who are different than whatever criteria they create, to be considered the One. She uses the quote from George Bernard Shaw, to exemplify this:
“The America white relegates the black to the rank of shoeshine boy; and he concludes from this that the black is good for nothing but shining shoes.” (Sterba, p330)
Sartre showed us that since the day of the hominids, the dominant male created his superiority by dialectically claiming all others are inferior, and that to an extent, before reason, this may have been considered true in the physical sense, that males were stronger than females, physically. This behavior developed as man developed. de Beauvoir shows us that with our newly developed reason, we must rise above this rationalistic western bias, this need to create the One, because it dehumanizes and belittles all those who are not considered to be the One. That while as Cavemen we may have needed to have the One, to survive in primitive hominid cultures, but this ancient bias in cognitive thinking is no longer true, and leads the horrors man has inflicted on others, even others who also consider themselves…to be the One.
REFERENCES
Sterba, James, Ethics, 2000, Oxford University Press, NY, NY
Wartenberg, Thomas, Existentialism, Oneworld Publications, Oxford, England